Disgusting chewy meat!!
This pie was absolutely awful the meat was so tough & chewy. Pastry and gravy nice. Won’t be buying this ever again.
Wish I had read the reviews first, very disapointe
Wish I had read the reviews first, very disapointed, the pastry was very hard on the edges -not crisp as is normal with a good pie crust - just hard and chewy like cardboard. There was quiet a bit of meat but it was hard and chewy - matched the pastry. I cannot believe that Tesco puts this pie in the finest range - its such poor quality. I occasionally have a pukka pie and they are far superior. Come on Tesco's get this sorted its a very bad quality pie - don't let people think its on par with the usual Finest Range. The dogs enjoyed it and so far they are still in good health.
Pretty good pastry, but a bit too thick. Filling not great, underseasoned but the dog loved it...
Tesco WORST , certainly not Finest. Zero stars
Bought this for New Year’s Day and have never been so disappointed in any item from Tesco. This pie was awful, meat was hard and chewy , not edible . Pastry encased the so called meat filling . The pastry was hard and awful. Had to bin it . Wish I had seen reviews before buying. Ruined my New Year’s Day. Tesco please remove this product as it’s really bad ,which you must be aware of because of the negative reviews. Please note I use the app which doesn’t show reviews. Zero stars !
Not up to Tesco Finest standard
If we could give 0 stars we would. About time Tesco stopped selling this product, or at least talk to their supplier about the quality of the meat. We agree with the other reviews, it was quite poor. It was as though it wasn’t cooked for long enough. We will not be buying again.
Not good enough to be called ‘Finest’.
Really good pastry topping, but the steak inside was far from good quality, very hard and chewy. The quality wasn’t as good as we were expecting. Would not buy again.
Do not buy, packet looks better than it tastes.
The meat was tough and the pastry was hard and definiteley not like puff pastry. Overall a very bland pie, would have given it half a star if I could have.
Wished I had looked at reviews before purchasing. The pie was the worst we have had - the steak was so tough, at best must have been stewing steak, and the gravy tasteless. The meat was lacking in quantity - no way could this pass as a pie for 2 people. The crust was like cardboard - could even turn the pie over to cut without anything leaking as normal pies would. This certainly doesn’t deserve a place on Tesco shelves never mind the Finest brand - agree with other comments - this needs to be removed from sale.
AVOID. Absolutely disgusting don’t waste your money. Pastry so thick you literally can’t cut through it - tough chewy ‘meat’ Most of it went in the food bin. Can’t remember the last time I tasted anything so awful! AVOID I wouldn’t even give it 1 star
Inedible. We threw it away.
Absolutely shockingly awful pie. Astonishing for a Finest product. The beef was so chewy it was impossible to swallow. We had to discard it and find another meal.