Not enough meat ...
Tasty pie but very little meat in it.
Worst pastry ever!
I stopped buying these a few years ago and thought that these pies might have improved. I was wrong. This is the worst pastry I have ever tried. Compressed tasteless cardboard, not puff pastry!
Very disappointed. Hard pastry not puff more gravy
Very disappointed. Hard pastry not puff more gravy than meat
Rubbish
Thought i would give one of these a try. I have had pukka and peters steak pies, delishious, but...omg. the teaco pie had no flavor, stodgy pastry and only 2 pieces of meat. NEVER again, not even on sale.
Would not recommend.
Would not recommend.
Room for improvement
... if only there were less air above the filling! The filling is tasty and the pastry is nice and crunchy cooked from frozen in the oven.
These are really gorgeous pies. The meat's great,
These are really gorgeous pies. The meat's great, the pie crust is lovely and the sauce is really nice too - you can actually taste the ale. I would recommend them.
Just don't, awful.
Dreadful. The pastry was like shortcrust not puff, hard and inedible. The filling was stark and the gravy was very watery with ZERO ale or beef flavoring, weak Bisto would be better! It's not a good pie at all and is very disappointing. A Pukka pie is 100% better for every reason mentioned and they are at the bottom of the pie scale! Save your money on these, avoid disappointment at it's greatest!
Agree a lot with what other reviewers have said. H
Agree a lot with what other reviewers have said. Hard pastry that I struggled to get a fork into. A tall pie half full of gravy with a paltry amount of meat in it. Wouldn't recommend.
Do yourself a favour and leave this on the shelf
The pie did have a smell of ale and the pastry was OK, which is about the most positive I can be about it. The content, however was bland, and a real disappointment. It had been a while since I have had any sort of pie so I was quite excited to give this a go.