Rubbery and tasteless
Always used to love this cheese seems to have changed not so strong and rubbery not buying any more
Very poor, surely this has been wrongly packed as
Very poor, surely this has been wrongly packed as mature when it is nothing of the sort. In fact it is nothing more than a low quality, tasteless and rubbery processed cheese passed off as cheddar. Will never buy another "cheese" of this label again.
Really disappointed with this cheese. It had a rubbery texture and very little flavour...reminded me of Edam or processed cheese. Would not buy again.
Bought this as my usual Tesco extra mature wasn't available. Definitely won't be buying Pilgrims choice again!! Was very much like processed cheese both in taste and texture, what taste it had that is. Thankfully my usual cheese is available online again this week.
Absolute rubbish what a con 😢
Having bought this cheese before I thought we was on a winner? It was bland. Looked and tasted like a damp piece of cardboard. A mighty tasty punch it most definitely was not. If you want apiece of cheese that's bland, this is the one to buy. Don't be conned, they something anything else S .Piper
It is most definitely not string cheese - plastic taste
This is the nicest cheese for strong cheese lovers
This is the nicest cheese for strong cheese lovers! Perfect for oatcakes or biscuits. The tastiest cheese I have found in a long time! I have to ration it or I could easily devour the lot, it's that good!
NOT extra strong cheddar
Beware. This is medium strength cheddar not the extra strong cheddar previously sold in almost identical packaging.
What's happened to it?
We usually buy this or Cathedral City depending on if either are on offer. However we bought Pilgrim's Choice in the new shape and it tasted really poor, just like processed cheese. Don't think we will bother again, we will stick with Cathedral City.
Not the cheddar for me
Compared to other cheddars this has a much more 'farmy' after taste which for me isn't what I like in cheddar cheese - prefer a smoother creamier flavour.