Horrendous, almost inedible.
Watery, bland sauce with visible blebs of coagulated oil. Tasteless pieces of fish. Horrible mash potato. Top took about an hour to brown.
Poor change to the Finest Fish Pie.
This used to be a favourite for us to by. Bought very recently and extremely disappointed with the 'change' to the receipt and quantities. I hope Tesco revert to their previous receipt, so we can get back to enjoying this dish.
Change back to old recipe!
Very disappointed with this when recently bought. Used to be a favourite treat, but the most recent pie seemed to be lacking in flavour/seasoning, and had a disproportionate amount of sauce compared to fish and mash. Won’t be buying again unless the recipe reverts.
This was a sloppy mess. I wondered whether it had been placed upside down before delivery and thought it would improve when cooked - it didn't! A few pieces of fish in an inedible, wet, sloppy mess. Won't buy this again.
ARE YOU NOT TAKING ANY NOTICE, TESCO??? Bought one for supper but not at all impressed. Gallons of sauce and very little fish. Disappointing, it used to be really good. I won't buy it again until Tesco wakeup and get it right.
Mash potato needs to be firmer.. Sauce also needs
Mash potato needs to be firmer.. Sauce also needs to be slightly thicker so that they don't mix together! Shame because this could be a good meal.
Great fish pie-needs more mash
Great quality fish and sauce but it needs more potato to soak up the sauce. I've been putting a couple of slices of potato underneath to soak up the liquid then its great. Heads up Tescos -please add more mash!!
Usually buy the Charlie Bighams fish pie but as it was sold out, picked up the Tesco fish pie instead. What a disappointment it turned out to be. Imagine it served on a plate and having to eat it with a spoon as it was so sloppy. Sorry. Won't be buying it again.
More like soup than fish pie
This was a favourite in our house until a few weeks ago when suddenly it was very watery - more like soup than fish pie. We’ve had three consecutive fish pies now - all watery and the white fish is grey. We won’t be buying this again. Such a pity as we used to love it. Have you changed supplier Tesco?
Sloppy and wet
This used to be lovely however they must have changed the recipe as it was very runny and there was a strong mustard taste too. There was no actual mash, it was just runny, yellow slop. I won’t be buying again. Disappointing for Tesco Finest.